Update: Some of the pricing information on this comparison review is now outdated. We will be updating information such as pricing and available subscription services soon. In the mean time, you can check out the latest updated pricing for Dollar Shave Club by following the link provided or check out shaving deals on Amazon by following that link.
Getting everyday products shipped right to your door seems to be the craze as of late. As we lead more busy lives and shipping gets cheaper it only makes sense to not have to be constantly making trips to the store to pick up small items. Razors for shaving is one of those items that most men use on a daily basis so we thought we would compare two of the top membership services in that category to give you a better feel for whom to chose.
Dollar Shave Club first hit the scene with a viral video that was seen by millions of people where they hilariously broke down why you need to get your razors delivered. Harry’s takes a different approach to the matter with a sleek, old-school, and no-nonsense vibe to their brand. Both brands offer a monthly blade refill service where you can get blades as well as shaving cream shipped to your door when you need it. So check out our Harry’s vs. Dollar Shave Club comparison below to figure out which is right for you.
Dollar Shave Club Plans
Dollar Shave Club has various options on what type of blade you’re sent monthly. The first month you will receive the handle along with the blades but every other month you will simply receive the blades. As you can see from the options, you have three different choices available with each level giving you more blades and hopefully a better shave.
The Humble – The Humble is the cheapest plan available and includes a razor that has two stainless steel blades and a lubricating strip. The plan is for $1 per month which includes 5 blade cartridges.
The 4X – The “4X” is the next step up with four stainless steel blades and a lubricating strip. This plan is priced at $6 per month and comes with 4 refill cartridges.
The Executive – The “Executive” is the top plan you can get at the moment with a premium razor that six stainless steel blades and a lubricating strip. It comes with 4 refill cartridges and is priced at $9 per month.
Dollar Shave Club is currently running a promotion where you can get your first month for $1. This also includes free shipping. No word on when this discount will end.
The options for Harry’s are slightly different than DSC as you aren’t necessarily just choosing a better blade as you go up. These packages are also just the starter packages and you must then enroll in the auto-refill. There are a few different sets to choose from depending on your preference including the Truman Set, Winston Set, Maple Leaf Set and more. Below we break down the plans available within the auto-refill. As you can see these plans are more about how often you need the razors shipped and less about which type of razor you prefer.
Everyday Shaver – The “Everyday Shaver” package is, of course, best for those who shave every day. This package will ship every two months with 8 blades and 2 creams.
Occasional Shaver – The “Occasional Shaver” is for those who shave a few days a week. The package ships every four months with 8 blades and 2 creams.
Infrequent Shaver – The “Infrequent Shaver” is best for those who only shave one day a week or less. The package will ship to your door every six months with 8 blades and 2 creams.
How Much Do They Cost
How Much Does Dollar Shave Club Cost?
The model of Dollar Shave Club is to give you a mix of low prices with the convenience of having razors delivered right to your door. The lowest priced plan available is for $1 per month with the premium package available for $9 per month. All of the plans do have a shipping charge which brings the price up $2 per plan.
How Much Does Harry’s Auto-Refill Cost?
Unlike Dollar Shave Club, Harry’s does their memberships by how often you shave. For some of us, you will have to shave every day to avoid looking like a caveman while others can go days without needing to shave. You can choose between the “Everyday Shaver” sent every 2 months, “Occasional Shaver” sent every 4 months, and the Infrequent Shaver” sent every 6 months. All of the packages have the same price at $31 per month with free shipping if you choose economy shipping. Each package comes with 8 blades and 2 creams. You can purchase through the official Harry’s website as well as kits from online stores like Amazon and more.
Is Either Service Really Worth It?
Do you really need Dollar Shave Club or Harry’s to deliver your razors? There are some within the shaving and men’s skincare industries who claim that aside from the customer service and delivery options you may be better off purchasing your blades on a place like Amazon. You can find a lot of different razors available on Amazon and when you sign up for the subscribe and save it will knock 5% off your total. For example, you can get a comparable razor to the “The Humble” from Dollar Shave Club with the Bic Twin Select on Amazon. The total price per blade includes shipping of the Bic from Amazon comes out to $0.36 whereas “The Humble” is $0.60 per blade. This is also factoring in that you have Amazon Prime to get free shipping. In many other cases, the razors will still ship free for even those who are not members as long as you make another purchase with the razors. So if you’re going for the cheapest blades instead of the best qualify then Amazon may end up being the best option.
It’s a little hard to compare the two services and give you an exact answer on which shaving membership service is better. If you’re looking for the cheaper product than you should go with the “Humble” plan from Dollar Shave Club which comes out to $3 per month with shipping. If you’re looking for higher quality at a decent price then you should probably choose one of the packages from Harry’s as their premium blades end up being cheaper than DSC on the higher-end models. They also include a premium shaving cream with each package at $8, which is the same as DSC’s Dr. Carver’s Easy Shave Butter. So overall there isn’t a huge gap between the two brands if you’re going on price, but in our opinion it comes down to whether you’re looking for a basic shave at a cheap price or a higher-end product at a fair market price with the convenience of being delivered to your door.
DEAL: If you're not interested in one of these shaving clubs or premium razors you can find a large selection of handpicked razors and shaving deals from Amazon. Most items also come with free shipping
Where To Buy Harry’s and Dollar Shave Club
In our opinion, the best places to buy their products are their official websites. Dollar Shave Club is sold exclusivly through their official website, so any other store you see selling their products online is probably either reselling at a higher price or isn’t legit. Harry’s is sold at a few different places at about the same price as you can find it on their website. The stores that currently sell Harry’s include Target, Nordstrom, Need Supply and a few others. We’ve yet to see either product on Amazon or other leading marketplaces. Leave any comments or your own reviews of these products below.